TL;DR
Small business owners in Chancellor John Healey’s South Yorkshire constituency say rising employment costs and proposed workers’ rights changes are making recruitment harder ahead of the Budget. A local chamber is calling for tax relief to support hiring, while a survey found more than half of member firms expect turnover and profitability to improve over the next year. Business owners’ accounts are views and individual experiences, not proof of a region-wide effect.
Small business owners in Chancellor John Healey’s South Yorkshire constituency say employment costs and planned workers’ rights changes are discouraging recruitment, ahead of a Budget they hope will address pressure on firms. Their concerns contrast with a local chamber survey showing improved expectations among member businesses, though the survey also found employers want further government action to sustain growth.
Get smart everyday buys delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Tony Airey, who has run Wentworth Garden Centre with his family for 40 years, told This Is Money that the business cut staff rather than hire additional workers last Christmas after rises in National Insurance contributions and the national minimum wage. It has 15 full-time employees as well as part-time and seasonal staff. Airey said further minimum wage increases could become “unsustainable” for the business.
Airey also criticised provisions in the government’s proposed Workers’ Rights Bill, including a right to sick pay from the first day of illness regardless of hours worked. He argued that the measures could deter employers from hiring, particularly younger people. These are his assessment of how the proposals may affect employers; the report does not quantify their effect on hiring across the constituency.
The Barnsley and Rotherham Chamber has called for direct action on National Insurance for workers under 25 and targeted tax reductions to ease energy and business-rate pressures. Chief executive Carrie Sudbury said those measures would give firms more scope to hire, invest and compete. At the same time, the chamber said its latest members’ survey found 57 per cent expected turnover to rise over the next year and 51 per cent expected profitability to improve, compared with 34 per cent expecting improved profitability in the previous quarter.
Sudbury said firms were ready to consider expansion and investment, but needed government action to maintain the more positive outlook. The figures reflect expectations among chamber members, not confirmed future results or all businesses in the area.
Hiring Costs Shape Local Business Plans
The dispute matters because staffing costs affect whether small firms can recruit, expand or maintain opening hours. Businesses that cannot afford additional workers may have less capacity to meet seasonal demand or grow. That concern is especially relevant to employers such as garden centres, pubs and independent shops, where staffing and energy expenses are part of day-to-day operating costs.
The accounts also show that business sentiment is not uniform. The chamber’s survey points to improving expectations, while individual owners describe constraints on hiring and spending. The Budget could affect both sides of that picture through decisions on employment costs, business rates and support for particular sectors. The source material does not establish what measures the Budget will contain or how any measure would change hiring in practice.
For workers and local communities, the issue is whether firms can create jobs and maintain services while meeting higher costs and employment standards. Calls to reduce the cost of hiring young people also raise questions about how support for employers would be balanced with workers’ rights. Those outcomes will depend on the policies announced and their implementation, rather than on business owners’ predictions alone.
Products Worth Considering

LG UltraGear 34-Inch Curved QHD Gaming Monitor, 160Hz, FreeSync Premium

Samsung 34-inch ViewFinity S50GC Ultra-WQHD Monitor

LG UltraGear 34G600A-B 34-Inch Curved WQHD Gaming Monitor
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Local Firms Enter Budget Week
The accounts in the report come from Rawmarsh, Wentworth and Conisbrough, communities in Healey’s South Yorkshire constituency. The article describes Conisbrough’s town centre as having many closed retail units and more charity shops, vape shops and takeaways than remaining independent businesses. It offers that as local reporting, not as a measured account of the wider region’s business performance.
Airey wrote to Healey after the previous Budget, saying it had offered no stimulus for growth in his sector and had created a block on recruitment and investment. He also argued that higher taxes could reduce the revenue collected, and said there was little incentive for people to take the personal and financial risk of starting a business. These are his views, rather than independently verified conclusions about the effects of tax policy.
There are also more hopeful voices. Chantry Brewery owner Mick Warburton said he saw signs that Healey and regional mayor Andy Burnham wanted to support hospitality. The brewery employs 35 people across its brewery, bar and three pubs. Warburton credited a previous small brewers’ relief scheme with helping the business start, but said pubs were struggling because customers had less money to spend. Healey has also promoted a 20 per cent business-rates cut for pubs, clubs and music venues, as described in the report.
“These mitigate against employers taking on more staff, particularly youngsters.”
— Tony Airey, Wentworth Garden Centre owner
Budget Measures Remain Undisclosed
The source report was published before the Budget and does not specify which policies the government would announce. It is therefore unclear whether ministers will change National Insurance, business rates, minimum wage policy or the Workers’ Rights Bill in response to the concerns raised.
The report also provides no estimate of how much the cited employment-cost changes have affected hiring across South Yorkshire, and no comparison showing how local firms’ costs or recruitment differ from those in other areas. The chamber survey records expectations, not final turnover or profit figures, and its sample size is not given in the material provided.
It remains unclear how the proposed sick-pay provisions will be implemented and what their eventual effect would be on recruitment, especially for younger workers. The experiences of Airey, Warburton and local shopkeepers illustrate individual concerns but cannot establish a general effect for all small businesses.
Budget Decisions Set the Next Test
The immediate next development is the Budget announcement referenced in the report. The government’s decisions on business taxation, employment costs and support for hospitality will show whether the chamber’s requests are addressed. The source material does not confirm the eventual contents of the Budget.
After any measures are announced, their practical effects will depend on eligibility, implementation dates and how much support individual firms receive. Business owners’ accounts and later chamber surveys may indicate whether hiring and investment plans change, but the survey figures currently available describe expectations rather than outcomes.
Key Questions
What are South Yorkshire business owners asking the government to do?
The Barnsley and Rotherham Chamber has called for action on National Insurance for workers under 25 and targeted tax reductions to ease energy and business-rate pressures. Individual owners have also raised concerns about minimum wages and employment rules.
What did the chamber’s survey find?
The chamber said 57 per cent of member firms expected turnover to rise over the coming year and 51 per cent anticipated improved profitability. The report compares the profitability figure with 34 per cent in the previous quarter; these are expectations, not confirmed results.
Is there evidence that the Workers’ Rights Bill has reduced hiring?
The report gives Airey’s view that the proposed provisions could discourage recruitment, particularly of younger workers. It does not provide data establishing that the bill has reduced hiring across the constituency.
What support has been described for pubs and hospitality?
The report says Healey promoted a 20 per cent business-rates cut for pubs, clubs and music venues. Brewery owner Mick Warburton welcomed signs of support but said pubs still faced weak customer spending. The report does not detail the cut’s eligibility rules or implementation.
What happens next?
The Budget announcement is the next milestone. Its published measures will show whether the government responds to the requests raised by local firms and the chamber; the source report does not state what the eventual policies will be.
Source: rss
